195
195
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
KTVU
tv
eye 195
favorite 0
quote 0
certainly he will be read his miranda rights. since this was an nbi arrest, he will be read his miranda rights. he doesn't have to ask for a lawyer, he could mamake statements that could later be used against him. you can ask for an attorney or you can make a statement. >> let me jump in here i want to check in with john king. john you're hearing more from -- >> i just want to pass along information from our producer carol credy. two federal law enforcement officials have confirmed to her they have identified the identity. it is the younger brother suspect number two that is in custody. now they say federal officials have verifieded the identity. the official i communicated with said in custody, unspecified medical needs. they are now sweeping the area. >> bryan, what are you seeing. what did you see go down? >> anderson we just observed the scene from a rooftop probably 500-yard away from the backyard area. it had calmed down but we did see some police activity in the backyard. flashlights moving around. a police chopper had ret
certainly he will be read his miranda rights. since this was an nbi arrest, he will be read his miranda rights. he doesn't have to ask for a lawyer, he could mamake statements that could later be used against him. you can ask for an attorney or you can make a statement. >> let me jump in here i want to check in with john king. john you're hearing more from -- >> i just want to pass along information from our producer carol credy. two federal law enforcement officials have confirmed...
145
145
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 145
favorite 0
quote 0
they believe that -- the feds actually, when they took him in, they suspended his miranda rights for a 48 hour period and decide whether or not to seek the death penalty -- listen to this from last night as well. >> this is still an active and ongoing investigation. we're going to be reviewing all of the evidence. before that kind of a decision is made in terms of whether or not to seek the death penalty, you review all of the evidence and it's a very thoughtful, long process that is engaged and it's the attorney general of the department of justice that makes that final decision. >> martha: all right. so there you have that. let's bring in fox news legal analyst peter johnson, jr. peter, welcome. >> how are you? >> martha: that's the u.s. attorney on this case in boston. she says it's too early to talk about death penalty. >> i was really surprised and disturbed as an american and as a lawyer in watching that last night. you couldn't think of a more weak insip mid remark that she was making. the charges that will be filed in this case, i haven't seen them, but i can approximate what
they believe that -- the feds actually, when they took him in, they suspended his miranda rights for a 48 hour period and decide whether or not to seek the death penalty -- listen to this from last night as well. >> this is still an active and ongoing investigation. we're going to be reviewing all of the evidence. before that kind of a decision is made in terms of whether or not to seek the death penalty, you review all of the evidence and it's a very thoughtful, long process that is...
179
179
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
CNNW
tv
eye 179
favorite 0
quote 0
certainly he will be read his miranda rights. this is obviously a very controversial subject involving terrorism investigations, but since this was an fbi arrest, this will -- he will be read his miranda rights. he doesn't have to ask for a lawyer. he could make statements that could later be used against him. that's after all what the miranda warnings are. you can have an attorney or you can make a statement. depending on -- >> jeff, let me jump in here. i want to check in with john king. >> -- he will either speak to -- >> john, you're hearing more? >> i just want to pass along information from our producer, who says two federal law enforcement officials have confirmed to her they have verified the identity. it is the younger brother, suspect number two, in custody. it is now they say federal officials verified the identity and have no doubt. as i said earlier, a federal official i communicated with said in custody, unspecified medical needs and they are now sweeping that scene to make sure there are no additional risks. >> bri
certainly he will be read his miranda rights. this is obviously a very controversial subject involving terrorism investigations, but since this was an fbi arrest, this will -- he will be read his miranda rights. he doesn't have to ask for a lawyer. he could make statements that could later be used against him. that's after all what the miranda warnings are. you can have an attorney or you can make a statement. depending on -- >> jeff, let me jump in here. i want to check in with john...
192
192
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
KNTV
tv
eye 192
favorite 0
quote 0
>> there are reports there was no miranda giving. they were claiming public safety kpenls. >> there is a public safety exemptions in days of national security and charges involving acts of terrorism. the government has that opportunity right now. i believe the suspect has been taken to a hospital. thank you. >> what's the federal death count? >> this is still an active, on going investigation. we'll review all of the evidence before that kind of decision is made in terms of whether or not to seek the death penalty you review all of the evidence. it's a very thoughtful, long process that is engaged. it's the attorney general of the department of justice that makes the final decision. >> commissioner -- >> i'm sorry. >> -- straight to the boat. can you or the colonel talk about what happened. was he moving around? how did you know it was a chance to take him into custody? >> we know he didn't go straight to the boat. when we set up the perimeter with the best intentions with a lot of information, we found blood in the car he abandoned,
>> there are reports there was no miranda giving. they were claiming public safety kpenls. >> there is a public safety exemptions in days of national security and charges involving acts of terrorism. the government has that opportunity right now. i believe the suspect has been taken to a hospital. thank you. >> what's the federal death count? >> this is still an active, on going investigation. we'll review all of the evidence before that kind of decision is made in terms...
156
156
Apr 27, 2013
04/13
by
CNNW
tv
eye 156
favorite 0
quote 0
talk to me about what more we know about that decision to read those miranda rights to dzhokhar tsarnaev when that happened. >> reporter: good morning, poppy. well we know that congressman rogers certainly wants to know more about the decision leading up to those rights being read because we know the suspect has become a lot less talkative after hearing those miranda rights. certainly he led investigators to look for the laptop, we learned from the suspect about the plans to go to new york but since he was read his rights he's gotten a lot less talkative and congressman rogers has written a letter to eric holder demanding a full accounting of the decision leading up to the initial appearance with the judge including who decided that appearance should take place at that specific place and time during this questioning and whether the department of justice or the fbi expressed any concerns about the timing of this and concerns about the fact that the suspect would now be read his miranda rights. i should tell you the department of justice hasn't yet responded directly to that letter to atto
talk to me about what more we know about that decision to read those miranda rights to dzhokhar tsarnaev when that happened. >> reporter: good morning, poppy. well we know that congressman rogers certainly wants to know more about the decision leading up to those rights being read because we know the suspect has become a lot less talkative after hearing those miranda rights. certainly he led investigators to look for the laptop, we learned from the suspect about the plans to go to new...
246
246
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 246
favorite 0
quote 0
there are exceptions to the miranda warning? >> there are exceptions to the miranda warnings. since the miranda case in 1966, the supreme court carved out a number of different exceptions where the police don't need to read the miranda warnings to a suspect and can still introduce in the statements that the suspects make into evidence. >>brian: do you believe this information warrants that exception? >> i do not. i think the government is taking a chance by deciding to go ahead and interview the suspect, future defendant without reading his miranda rights. the exception that they are citing is the public safety exception from a 1984 case, where a suspect was arrested after putting a loaded gun somewhere that supermarket. as the police were driving away, they asked him what he did with the gun, and he told them where it was. the police were able to recover a loaded gun. but in that case the danger to the public was immediate. here, i think we're talking about potentially interviewing this guy, the younger brother, when he wakes up in the hospital after the police have been sati
there are exceptions to the miranda warning? >> there are exceptions to the miranda warnings. since the miranda case in 1966, the supreme court carved out a number of different exceptions where the police don't need to read the miranda warnings to a suspect and can still introduce in the statements that the suspects make into evidence. >>brian: do you believe this information warrants that exception? >> i do not. i think the government is taking a chance by deciding to go...
107
107
Apr 23, 2013
04/13
by
CNNW
tv
eye 107
favorite 0
quote 0
>> it's not clear whether he provided this information before or after he was read his miranda rights. i don't know. . i know, this is according to a government source, what he has told them in the preliminary investigations. >> jake tapper, thank you very much. obviously significant information there. new information from jake tapper. i want to bring in our panel live tonight. seth jones associate director of the security defense policy center at the rand corporation. former member of the joint terrorism task force and jeffrey toobin our legal analyst. jake is saying -- this is significant in terms of the information in this. but obviously a crucial question out there which is was it obtained before or after those miranda rights were read? >> the irony here is what he is saying is not particularly helpful to him. what would be helpful to him is if he had a conspiracy he could make the government to make a deal to avoid the death penalty. if he is simply saying it is me and my brother, what does he have to negotiate with? >> there's no one to else to give up. >> right. >> and frankly,
>> it's not clear whether he provided this information before or after he was read his miranda rights. i don't know. . i know, this is according to a government source, what he has told them in the preliminary investigations. >> jake tapper, thank you very much. obviously significant information there. new information from jake tapper. i want to bring in our panel live tonight. seth jones associate director of the security defense policy center at the rand corporation. former member...
165
165
Apr 22, 2013
04/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 165
favorite 0
quote 0
it's not a way around the miranda ruling. the miranda ruling requires all government agencies to tell you before they ask you a question you don't have to answer it. the obama administration has taken a radical approach to the miranda rule by coming out of nowhere with this 48 hour rule that doesn't exist in any statute and no court has permitted it. >> going to regret it? >> i think they will. bass opposite they start using it there will be no stop to it. >> shepard: investigators want to talk with the wife of the older bombing suspect. are lawyer says she won't be able to tell them much because she had no idea he was up to anything until she saw he was a suspect on television. that part of the story is next. updating our breaking news. authorities in canada are expected to announce multiple arrests relate toad what they're calling a major bomb plot. we're now getting conflicting reports about whether new york city was on a target list. sources telling fox news, at laos one man was arrested in quebec, another in ontario. tha
it's not a way around the miranda ruling. the miranda ruling requires all government agencies to tell you before they ask you a question you don't have to answer it. the obama administration has taken a radical approach to the miranda rule by coming out of nowhere with this 48 hour rule that doesn't exist in any statute and no court has permitted it. >> going to regret it? >> i think they will. bass opposite they start using it there will be no stop to it. >> shepard:...
141
141
Apr 22, 2013
04/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 141
favorite 0
quote 0
miranda rights read. so he may well cooperate and this may well all have a happy ending and i hope it does and i hope everything works out just fine. there is at least a chance that some information will be lost because of this and it seems to me that when you have an attack of this kind related to muslim extremism as this plainly is especially in the case of the older brother perhaps in the case of this young man as well that intelligence is critical and ought to be a priority. >> bret: yuan, we don't know what if anything he has told investigators up until he was read his miranda rights. that's what we don't know. he is clearly not speaking because of the injury. but, your thoughts? >> i was going to make the point that you made, which is that we don't know what he said before he was read his miranda rights. and it would indicate from the fact that he is nodding that maybe he wasn't able to speak. maybe, i don't know but that's my assumption based on the transcript. i will say i don't think the presiden
miranda rights read. so he may well cooperate and this may well all have a happy ending and i hope it does and i hope everything works out just fine. there is at least a chance that some information will be lost because of this and it seems to me that when you have an attack of this kind related to muslim extremism as this plainly is especially in the case of the older brother perhaps in the case of this young man as well that intelligence is critical and ought to be a priority. >> bret:...
114
114
Apr 23, 2013
04/13
by
KQED
tv
eye 114
favorite 0
quote 0
it was unclear if he was read his miranda rights. but in washington, white house spokesman jay carney said he's a naturalized u.s. citizen, so he will not face a military tribunal. >> he will not be treated as an enemy combatant. we will prosecute this terrorist through our civilian system of justice, under us law. u.s. citizen can not be trialed, tried rather in military commissions. and it's important to remember that since 9-11 we have used the federal court system to convict and incarcerate hundreds of terrorists. >> brown: tsarnaev was also likely to face state charges in the shooting death of a police officer at m.i.t. it all followed his dramatic capture friday evening, when he was found hiding and wounded in a boat behind a home in the boston suburb of watertown. his older brother tamarlen died hours earlier in a shoot-out with police that triggered the all-day manhunt and shut down the city. yesterday, on cbs, massachusetts governor deval patrick stood by the unprecedented measures. >> i think people understood that we were
it was unclear if he was read his miranda rights. but in washington, white house spokesman jay carney said he's a naturalized u.s. citizen, so he will not face a military tribunal. >> he will not be treated as an enemy combatant. we will prosecute this terrorist through our civilian system of justice, under us law. u.s. citizen can not be trialed, tried rather in military commissions. and it's important to remember that since 9-11 we have used the federal court system to convict and...
202
202
Apr 27, 2013
04/13
by
CNNW
tv
eye 202
favorite 0
quote 0
but he's clammed up since he was read his miranda rights. athena jones is at the white house this morning. good morning, athena. >> good morning. this has been controversial. in fact, house intelligence committee chairman mike rogers wants to know more about why the suspect was read his miranda rights when he was read them. he sent a letter to the attorney general demanding a full accounting of how the decision was reached. it contained multiple questions including who decided that the initial appearance on monday should be held at that specific time and in the hospital while the questioning was ongoing. he also wants to know if the fbi raised concerns about the timing of the reading to the suspect of his right to remain silennd right to a lawyer. those are some questions that he's asking. the department of justice hasn't responded directly to the long list of questions in the l congressman's leer, but prosecutors and fbi agents knew this initial appearance had been scheduled ahead of time. i can also tell you that susan candiotti talked to
but he's clammed up since he was read his miranda rights. athena jones is at the white house this morning. good morning, athena. >> good morning. this has been controversial. in fact, house intelligence committee chairman mike rogers wants to know more about why the suspect was read his miranda rights when he was read them. he sent a letter to the attorney general demanding a full accounting of how the decision was reached. it contained multiple questions including who decided that the...
59
59
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
FBC
tv
eye 59
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> no miranda warning? >> it is a federal issue somebody else can explain that. >> there was no miranda warning given can we have an explanation? >> there is a public safety exemption with cases of national security with federal charges with an act of terrorism so the government has the opportunity right now so i believe the suspect has been taken to a hospital. thank you. >> is there a federal death penalty? >> i indicated earlier this is an active and ongoing investigation we will be reviewing all of the evidence before that decision is made in terms of whether or not to seek the death penalty. you review all of the evidence and it is a thoughtful, long process that is engaged and the attorney general of the department of justice that makes the final decision. >> can you tell us what happens at the scene was the moving around? how did you know, ? >> we know he did not go straight to the boat. when we set up the perimeter with the best intentions with a lot of information and finding blood in the car , beh
. >> no miranda warning? >> it is a federal issue somebody else can explain that. >> there was no miranda warning given can we have an explanation? >> there is a public safety exemption with cases of national security with federal charges with an act of terrorism so the government has the opportunity right now so i believe the suspect has been taken to a hospital. thank you. >> is there a federal death penalty? >> i indicated earlier this is an active and...
152
152
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
KRON
tv
eye 152
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> was there no miranda warning given? >> there is a public safety exception in case its separate security or act of terrorism. these widely believed that the suspect has been taken to an a hospital. what i indicated earlier that this is an active and ongoing situation. this is a very awful long process and ongoing investigation. >> can you talk to us a little bit about the suspect? >> we know that he did not go straight to the boat. we took the best intentions for what what information was given. we had no information it was very chaotic early this morning, we had a police officer that was shot and bleeding. so there was a lot of things going on. but he had to be moving an little bit because he was a behind the house for a certain period of time. >> were you all watching when he was moving all around? >> we have bay was called a forward looking device that picked up the heat signature even though he was our he was covered in shrink wrap. the helicopter was able to direct the team to that area. it was outside the perimeter
. >> was there no miranda warning given? >> there is a public safety exception in case its separate security or act of terrorism. these widely believed that the suspect has been taken to an a hospital. what i indicated earlier that this is an active and ongoing situation. this is a very awful long process and ongoing investigation. >> can you talk to us a little bit about the suspect? >> we know that he did not go straight to the boat. we took the best intentions for...
71
71
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 71
favorite 0
quote 0
was told there was an exchange of gunfire, i was not there when he was taken out of the boat. >> no miranda warning, do you want to explain that to us. >> that is a federal issue.
was told there was an exchange of gunfire, i was not there when he was taken out of the boat. >> no miranda warning, do you want to explain that to us. >> that is a federal issue.
65
65
Apr 23, 2013
04/13
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 65
favorite 0
quote 0
miranda rights. we've watched enough detective shows no know, police shows, they give miranda rights almost like blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. it's done. why do you think that's an issue? now we just got the word as we went on the air tonight the defendant here, the suspect, i guess he's a defendant now, has been given his miranda rights. >> this is truly something of an urban legend. people like to watch shows where a criminal goes free because he wasn't given miranda rights. that's extremely rare. i do criminal defense work. i can tell you, the most you can hope for in a miranda case is one or two statements will not make it into court. it's rare the whole case falls out unless everything -- >> so it's not the poison fruit thing? >> there is a poison fruit provision, standard. but it's very rare for it to pollute an entire case. >> let me ask you practically, why don't the law enforcement officials, the federal officials up there who have him in custody at the hospital, why didn't they just do this
miranda rights. we've watched enough detective shows no know, police shows, they give miranda rights almost like blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. it's done. why do you think that's an issue? now we just got the word as we went on the air tonight the defendant here, the suspect, i guess he's a defendant now, has been given his miranda rights. >> this is truly something of an urban legend. people like to watch shows where a criminal goes free because he wasn't given miranda rights. that's...
615
615
Apr 22, 2013
04/13
by
CURRENT
tv
eye 615
favorite 0
quote 0
so behavior mirandaizeing him the cops asked him where is the gun. before finding out asking if there were other bombs, beth i'm with you. but now they broadened it, besides asking about the becomes, ask him about other items. joe, it sounded like you were going to say one last thing on this. >> the last summation is in boston they've seen terror trials before, the richard reed trial. the shoe bomber, there was no miranda exception even then when there could and there was a direct link to an al-qaeda plot, and they ordered people to stay inside so they were confident that there was no explosive devices to begin with. i think it was a show of force by the federal government to let everybody know that they were doing everything they can short of torture, which is now illegal, to get information out of him. >> cenk: let me see if i can take this to the next level. peter king said he should be a combatant. >> i want the intelligence to save americans lives. and that's the only way to do that effectively if he's treated as enemy combatant. >> there is fin
so behavior mirandaizeing him the cops asked him where is the gun. before finding out asking if there were other bombs, beth i'm with you. but now they broadened it, besides asking about the becomes, ask him about other items. joe, it sounded like you were going to say one last thing on this. >> the last summation is in boston they've seen terror trials before, the richard reed trial. the shoe bomber, there was no miranda exception even then when there could and there was a direct link to...
178
178
May 1, 2013
05/13
by
CNNW
tv
eye 178
favorite 0
quote 0
perhaps maybe even significant for the miranda timing as well, which we all know there is a public safety exception which precludes you from having to mirandize as perhaps others in the case. i also want to report that at no time is there an actual tie to the actual bomb making or the carrying out of the actual crime itself with regard to these suspects. these are all issues after the fact as we're being told by the homeland security source. so a lot developing at this point live on location here in boston, wolf. >> ashleigh, standby for a moment. let's get some legal analysis of what's going on. professor alan dershowitz is there on the ground in boston. he's the harvard law professor joining us now. alan, let's go through these specific charges, if these students, at least two of them arrested on making false statements and conspiracy to obstruct justice, we know they've been questioned now over the more than two weeks basically going back to the days that they discovered -- nearly two weeks i should say, the day they discovered the tsarnaev brothers were involved in this and these are
perhaps maybe even significant for the miranda timing as well, which we all know there is a public safety exception which precludes you from having to mirandize as perhaps others in the case. i also want to report that at no time is there an actual tie to the actual bomb making or the carrying out of the actual crime itself with regard to these suspects. these are all issues after the fact as we're being told by the homeland security source. so a lot developing at this point live on location...
15
15
tv
eye 15
favorite 0
quote 0
as the participation of any per possible further accomplices and of course we have to note that the miranda rights off tonight have been revoked the right and he has to remain silent as well as a right to a lawyer are being deny to him because officials are interested in being able to question him without being able to use this right and the fact that his miranda rights have been revoked is receiving major criticism throughout the united states and causing really a lot of debate civil rights groups are saying that he should be able to have these rights provided to him. a u.s. citizen being investigated in a criminal case but certainly this is not been the case officials are using the public safety clause and the criticism stems from the fact that they did say earlier that any immediate threat has been removed also it's important to mention that republican lawmakers in the united states have been suggest. that i have been treated as an enemy competent this is also been a topic of much debate because we are of course talking about a us citizen or ny and didn't become a naturalized citizen las
as the participation of any per possible further accomplices and of course we have to note that the miranda rights off tonight have been revoked the right and he has to remain silent as well as a right to a lawyer are being deny to him because officials are interested in being able to question him without being able to use this right and the fact that his miranda rights have been revoked is receiving major criticism throughout the united states and causing really a lot of debate civil rights...
105
105
Apr 28, 2013
04/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 105
favorite 0
quote 0
>> they invoked the public safety exception to miranda. more important point he should have been treated as a potential enemy combatant. we want to know what they were trying to do but who his brother or who he was in touch with, how was he radicalized. was anyone overseas giving them help. >> paul: that can be drawn later and then sent to civilian court. when we come back as roll out continues, is obamacare unraveling? one of chief architects seems to think so. he is predicting a train wreck and getting off before the crash. can you get off, too? what if this feeling could last all week? with centurylink as your trusted partner, it can. our visionary cloud infrastructure and global broadband network free you to focus on what matters. with custom communications solutions and dedicated support, your business can shine all week long. ♪ ♪ >> ul >>. >> paul: well, who could blame them? congressional leaders from both parties have been this secret negotiations to exempt themselves from obamacare exchanges a claim that harry reid kenz this c
>> they invoked the public safety exception to miranda. more important point he should have been treated as a potential enemy combatant. we want to know what they were trying to do but who his brother or who he was in touch with, how was he radicalized. was anyone overseas giving them help. >> paul: that can be drawn later and then sent to civilian court. when we come back as roll out continues, is obamacare unraveling? one of chief architects seems to think so. he is predicting a...
19
19
tv
eye 19
favorite 0
quote 0
rights too early in the interrogation process republicans right or should have have been read his miranda rights even earlier also the tragic explosion in west texas should be a wake up call for all of us join us the importance of effective regulation some people it's not that way i'll talk with one of those people coming up and later in the show your take my take live segment your chance to call in and ask a question or make a comment while on the air. you need to know this new reports reveal the dzhokhar star and have the surviving boston marathon bombing suspect either stopped talking to investigators after he was read his miranda rights or wasn't read his miranda rights until after he'd much said everything he had to say and republicans are jumping on these revelations to justify either even further fudging of the constitution when law enforcement officials first captured the nineteen year olds are to have last friday president obama announced the federal investigators would not immediately read him his miranda rights and only when someone is arrested arresting officers are required t
rights too early in the interrogation process republicans right or should have have been read his miranda rights even earlier also the tragic explosion in west texas should be a wake up call for all of us join us the importance of effective regulation some people it's not that way i'll talk with one of those people coming up and later in the show your take my take live segment your chance to call in and ask a question or make a comment while on the air. you need to know this new reports reveal...
88
88
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 88
favorite 0
quote 0
was signal would by not reading the miranda rights when they captured him. it could mean that and could mean the opposite of that. in the meantime eric shaun has the latest from boston right now. >> hi, neil, they could be filing them under a civilian case under those chargeless. federal charge of at the same time state murder charges and that's what sources are telling fox newings, the reason he was not given the miranda rights is that under the law, under a approximate exemption that has to do with immediate threats to the police or public. there is a part of the law that said you don't have to give miranda rights to a suspect to immediately protect the police in a life or death situation. the idea is that when they got him in the boat, they don't know if there are other plots or bombs or devices that the brothers had allege wouldly planted. that was a way to get immediate information about the type of threat they may have posed. dzhokhar remains here in the hospital in serious condition. he lost a lot of blood and suffered two gunshot wounds one in the ne
was signal would by not reading the miranda rights when they captured him. it could mean that and could mean the opposite of that. in the meantime eric shaun has the latest from boston right now. >> hi, neil, they could be filing them under a civilian case under those chargeless. federal charge of at the same time state murder charges and that's what sources are telling fox newings, the reason he was not given the miranda rights is that under the law, under a approximate exemption that...
148
148
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 148
favorite 0
quote 0
there's too much misinformation about miranda. we're looking at it based on television programs tv series. if there's a miranda violation, that means that that statement that individual made can't be used in a court of law against him. however, this individual -- julian is right, the fbi is gathering that -- they already said they took full responsibility to it to the person whose car they carjacked. all they mean is statements you get are admissible. it's an affirmative defense on an evidentiary point. >> so your point is, just so i can clarify, your point is, we can still very likely put this guy in jail, or get the death penalty, whatever we decide. we may not need any of these statements against him in court. why not interrogate him for public safety reasons longs as long as we want? >> jay is right. the guy confessed in the carjacking. the terror suspect confessed to being the boston bomber. tim think mcveigh was mirandized. there isn't a problem here, which is why i'm surprised that senator graham, senator mccain and others
there's too much misinformation about miranda. we're looking at it based on television programs tv series. if there's a miranda violation, that means that that statement that individual made can't be used in a court of law against him. however, this individual -- julian is right, the fbi is gathering that -- they already said they took full responsibility to it to the person whose car they carjacked. all they mean is statements you get are admissible. it's an affirmative defense on an...
118
118
Aug 20, 2013
08/13
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 118
favorite 0
quote 0
miranda. and, you know, this is not the first incidence after the nsa leaks of learning that the u.k. government and spy agencies and the u.s. government have been working together with various surveillance programs and related issues. >> what more do you know regarding the destruction of these hard drives? "the guardian" editor in chief said the destruction of the computer hard drives contain information provided by whistleblower edward snowden and allowed the paper to continue reporting on the allegations. what do we know about this information? >> we don't know a lot because he's quite rightly keeping tight lipped on what he and the government have discussed. but what we are seeing is, you know, government intervention on perfectly valid journalistic activity. the guardian worked with the government to ensure that no, you know, national security items that could be of danger to national security were published. but we do understand that there is a continued pressure from both the u.s. gover
miranda. and, you know, this is not the first incidence after the nsa leaks of learning that the u.k. government and spy agencies and the u.s. government have been working together with various surveillance programs and related issues. >> what more do you know regarding the destruction of these hard drives? "the guardian" editor in chief said the destruction of the computer hard drives contain information provided by whistleblower edward snowden and allowed the paper to continue...
17
17
tv
eye 17
favorite 0
quote 0
nineteen year old dzhokhar and twenty six year old to milan and of course we have to note that the miranda rights have been revoked the rights he has to remain silent as well as the rights to a lawyer are being denied to him because officials are interested in being able to question him without being able to use this right and the fact that his miranda rights have been revoked is receiving major criticism throughout the united states and causing really a lot of debate between certain politicians and civil rights groups also it's important to mention that republican lawmakers in the united states have been suggesting that to be treated as an enemy competent this is also been a topic of much debate because we are of course talking about a u.s. citizen as we do know back in two thousand and eleven they did receive a request from a foreign government this is russia's government that said that they should look into the identity of the older brother the older suspect to milan back that he was twenty four years. hold and the f.b.i. did receive recommendations that they investigate him they did in
nineteen year old dzhokhar and twenty six year old to milan and of course we have to note that the miranda rights have been revoked the rights he has to remain silent as well as the rights to a lawyer are being denied to him because officials are interested in being able to question him without being able to use this right and the fact that his miranda rights have been revoked is receiving major criticism throughout the united states and causing really a lot of debate between certain...
13
13
tv
eye 13
favorite 0
quote 0
to federal officials the situation in the decision not to initially read him his miranda rights when he was arrested highlights the fact that we as a nation are once again on the edge of national is stereo today some are still suggesting that we have to balance our constitutional rights with security. and that it was a good thing we did so by not initially telling. of his joke our sunny of his fifth amendment rights as ben franklin so famously asserted if we're going to go down the road of compromising our rights for security will deserve and almost certainly end up with neither our fifth amendment rights are among our most important because they protect us from abuse of and by the one single institution that we have empowered to imprison and even kill us which is our government the government of the united states is an extraordinary and precious thing from its beginning is a noble experiment in freedom and democracy today but like all governments with the power to grant life and death it needs clear constraints committing horrible crimes even acts of terrorism wrong brutal horrible
to federal officials the situation in the decision not to initially read him his miranda rights when he was arrested highlights the fact that we as a nation are once again on the edge of national is stereo today some are still suggesting that we have to balance our constitutional rights with security. and that it was a good thing we did so by not initially telling. of his joke our sunny of his fifth amendment rights as ben franklin so famously asserted if we're going to go down the road of...
131
131
Apr 28, 2013
04/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 131
favorite 0
quote 0
do they believe there was a mistake there in reading miranda rights so early? >> we talked to him and democratic senator joe manchin and they expressed considerable distress. it's not the judge, once he had been formally charged on a criminal charge in federal court the judge that went over the next day on monday to the hospital had to notify him of his miranda rights. the question is why was the department of justice in such a hurry to charge him in a criminal case not to continue to question him either not reading his miranda rights or call him an enemy combatant. why were they soe in such a hurry to charge him to be lawyered up and stop talking? >> heather: we can get all more on your interviews. >> no miranda rights for me, thank you, heather. >> heather: you'll have more on texas congressman michael mccall and john manchin and chris is signature down to israeli ambassador to the u.s. it airs at 2:00 p.m. and 6:00 p.m. only on fox. >> eric: they are remembering and offering sunday morning prayers in boston. coming up, more survivors are speaking out. they a
do they believe there was a mistake there in reading miranda rights so early? >> we talked to him and democratic senator joe manchin and they expressed considerable distress. it's not the judge, once he had been formally charged on a criminal charge in federal court the judge that went over the next day on monday to the hospital had to notify him of his miranda rights. the question is why was the department of justice in such a hurry to charge him in a criminal case not to continue to...
15
15
tv
eye 15
favorite 0
quote 0
rights or wasn't read his miranda rights until after he'd pretty much said everything he had to say and republicans are jumping on these revelations to justify either even further fudging of the constitution when law enforcement officials first captured the nineteen year olds are to have last friday president obama announced the federal investigators would not immediately read him his miranda rights and only when someone is arrested arresting officers are required to remind them of their right to not incriminate themselves and to be. represented by an attorney the fifth amendment right against self incrimination is among our most important constitutional protections because it protects us from abuse of and by the one single institution that we have empowered to imprison and even legally kill us our government but in certain situations for example when an individual in custody knows the whereabouts of a ticking bomb the supreme court has ruled the police can interrogate that individual before reminding him or her of their miranda rights this is the so-called public safety exception i
rights or wasn't read his miranda rights until after he'd pretty much said everything he had to say and republicans are jumping on these revelations to justify either even further fudging of the constitution when law enforcement officials first captured the nineteen year olds are to have last friday president obama announced the federal investigators would not immediately read him his miranda rights and only when someone is arrested arresting officers are required to remind them of their right...
73
73
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
CNNW
tv
eye 73
favorite 0
quote 0
i don't think the miranda argument is particularly important in the end. they'll convict him if he lives. and if they don't give him miranda warnings, maybe they'll get more information about if there are other individual involved in this conspiracy. >> do you think that's part of it? other individuals involved? as someone who's been in the situations before, how big a concern is that, of the decisions tonight? >> sure. it's not about getting additional evidence against him. the public safety exception is to find out whether or not there is explosive devices out there that would cause some harm to the public -- >> which they're worried about. they don't know where all the pipe bomb went. >> sure. it's an absolute right to use the public safety exception in these circumstances. or is there an act of conspiracy beyond him and his brother. that's important for law enforcement to get to the heart of that as quickly as possible. >> that's an important point. we've been talking about, you know, they thought during the day that he could have some of those pipe bo
i don't think the miranda argument is particularly important in the end. they'll convict him if he lives. and if they don't give him miranda warnings, maybe they'll get more information about if there are other individual involved in this conspiracy. >> do you think that's part of it? other individuals involved? as someone who's been in the situations before, how big a concern is that, of the decisions tonight? >> sure. it's not about getting additional evidence against him. the...
86
86
Apr 22, 2013
04/13
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 86
favorite 0
quote 0
that window now has closed that limited scope that they were able to focus on before reading him his miranda rights? >> not necessarily. that could go independently. i guess now that they've had this initial appearance, i suppose that's a fair assumption. it isn't automatic but that's probably right. >> what about michael isikoff, our colleague is reporting that i.c.e. homeland security has focused on new bedford, massachusetts and two individuals were taken in for immigration violations and they apparently are friends of tamerlan tsarnaev. can you tell me any more about that? >> these are people, i presume he is talking about people detained in new bedford, massachusetts on friday evening. the fbi has been trying to investigate whether they had any knowledge of this. whether they had any role in it. they seem to have concluded that they don't. but they're being held for now on immigration charges pending further investigation. >> and before i let you go, i know you have more to cover. 2009, this police report of tamerlan tsarnaev being arrested on domestic violence allegations. that has bee
that window now has closed that limited scope that they were able to focus on before reading him his miranda rights? >> not necessarily. that could go independently. i guess now that they've had this initial appearance, i suppose that's a fair assumption. it isn't automatic but that's probably right. >> what about michael isikoff, our colleague is reporting that i.c.e. homeland security has focused on new bedford, massachusetts and two individuals were taken in for immigration...
143
143
Apr 30, 2013
04/13
by
CNNW
tv
eye 143
favorite 0
quote 0
about these miranda rights. the one thing i want to say about the stove piping issue, that's another thing that has become completely partisan. i talked to diane finestein. it's sad, it's probably not surprising, but it is unbelievable, how quickly it's happened. >> what's sad to me is the republican right are forever telling us that the constitution is their sacred text. it's not a debatable question whether this guy could be held incompetent. it is against the constitution of the yiet to do that. if they want to rip the constitution up, at the slightest hint of terrorism -- >> but something that concerns me is the right hand not knowing what the left hand is doing. >> they were completely surprised. >> why aren't you defending the constitution? >> i am defending the constitution. jeffrey, i have a question for you, as a lawyer, my understanding is that detained suspects don't have a right to have the miranda rights read to them. they have those rights and they can choose to exercise them. i know it's a little
about these miranda rights. the one thing i want to say about the stove piping issue, that's another thing that has become completely partisan. i talked to diane finestein. it's sad, it's probably not surprising, but it is unbelievable, how quickly it's happened. >> what's sad to me is the republican right are forever telling us that the constitution is their sacred text. it's not a debatable question whether this guy could be held incompetent. it is against the constitution of the yiet...
123
123
Aug 20, 2013
08/13
by
CNNW
tv
eye 123
favorite 0
quote 0
now miranda is taking legal action against the british government. joining me now from london is our cnn senior international correspondent matthew chance. matthew, this seems to be getting pretty ugly with glenn greenwald focusing his energies on releasing information pertaining to london. >> reporter: they haven't released reaction to that threat. glenn greenwald has an e-mail to reuters news agency that said he would not be releasing any documents he wasn't otherwise going to publish as an act of revenge. he's been seeking to play that down. there has been reaction here to the detention of david miranda both from british authorities who say it was totally justified and from human rights activists who say this was something that was unnecessary and abuse of anti-terrorism laws in this country. as you mentioned, of course, the lawyers representing david miranda say they will be challenging that detention in the courts very shortly. >> what are people there saying about this? do they feel as though this is legitimate that this person was detained und
now miranda is taking legal action against the british government. joining me now from london is our cnn senior international correspondent matthew chance. matthew, this seems to be getting pretty ugly with glenn greenwald focusing his energies on releasing information pertaining to london. >> reporter: they haven't released reaction to that threat. glenn greenwald has an e-mail to reuters news agency that said he would not be releasing any documents he wasn't otherwise going to publish...
28
28
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 28
favorite 0
quote 0
in terms of what he is waiting for from his miranda. you know it from "law and order." you have the right to remain silent. you have the right to consult an attorney before speaking to the police. if you cannot afford an attorney one will be appointed for you before any questions if you wish. if you decide to answer any questions without an attorney you will still have the right to stop answering. are you willing to answer my questions without an attorney present? it's not always exactly like that and in the movies the person saying it usually has a much cooler accent but that's pretty much the idea. your statements are only admissible in court if they come after you've been told that list of things about your rights. there is a public safety exception for questions that just had to be asked of you urgently for legitimate public safety need even if those questions came before you got read the miranda. the obama administration has extended the reach of that public safety exemption so it can last longer to attend to the public safety threats that could accrue in terrorism
in terms of what he is waiting for from his miranda. you know it from "law and order." you have the right to remain silent. you have the right to consult an attorney before speaking to the police. if you cannot afford an attorney one will be appointed for you before any questions if you wish. if you decide to answer any questions without an attorney you will still have the right to stop answering. are you willing to answer my questions without an attorney present? it's not always...
189
189
Apr 23, 2013
04/13
by
CNNW
tv
eye 189
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> they can do that at any time even after they read him his miranda rights? >> yes, that's my view. >> so that changes nothing in view of their ability to interrogate? >> what it changes is their ability to question him and use any statement that he makes. that they're not allowed to do. >> he is apparently claiming -- >> they don't need that in this case. they got a mountain of evidence against this guy. >> right. they have testified it seems against him and his brother for the act they perpetrated. >> correct. >> what they will i'm sure be extremely curious to find out if they can is are they part of a wider group of either like-minded individuals who have been coordinating themselves reading stuff on the internet, videos and so on, which apparently is what he's claiming. whether they're attached to anybody in chechnya, for example, or islamic fundamentalist nature, et cetera, et cetera, how far can you go in terms of eliciting that information from somebody like him in his position once he's had his miranda rights read to him as he now has? >> my view is y
. >> they can do that at any time even after they read him his miranda rights? >> yes, that's my view. >> so that changes nothing in view of their ability to interrogate? >> what it changes is their ability to question him and use any statement that he makes. that they're not allowed to do. >> he is apparently claiming -- >> they don't need that in this case. they got a mountain of evidence against this guy. >> right. they have testified it seems...
93
93
Apr 23, 2013
04/13
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 93
favorite 0
quote 1
but also on the same time now we have a suspect who already was read his miranda rights. he already have a lawyer present. and i don't think that should affect any trained interrogator, any trained interviewer in doing their job. we have been doing this for many, many years. we did it against terrorist suspects, organized crimes, people who are charged with treason, spies, and it always worked, and it always gets the intended results. >> in terms of this breaking news that we've just got tonight. again, this is a senior government official saying that the initial interrogation of dzhokhar tsarnaev in his hospital bed, he says that he and his brother were not in touch with any overseas terrorists or groups. they conceived the attack on their own, motivated he told them by religious fervor. that's the language that i have been given. how -- how should that be approached in terms of strategically trying to unwind any threats that might exist beyond these young men? they're saying they acted alone. but presumably, the thing that made them want to do this could make other peop
but also on the same time now we have a suspect who already was read his miranda rights. he already have a lawyer present. and i don't think that should affect any trained interrogator, any trained interviewer in doing their job. we have been doing this for many, many years. we did it against terrorist suspects, organized crimes, people who are charged with treason, spies, and it always worked, and it always gets the intended results. >> in terms of this breaking news that we've just got...
173
173
Apr 28, 2013
04/13
by
CNNW
tv
eye 173
favorite 0
quote 0
and that quest for new information seems to have stalled since suspect dzhokhar tsarnaev was read his miranda rights leading some to criticize that move. now the administration is responding to that criticism and pamela is live with that story. i know you're standing at the prison hospital where dzhokhar is being held. what is the administration saying at this hour? >> well, poppy, my colleague brianna keilar spoke to attorney general eric holder last night at the white house correspondents' dinner in washington and he commented publicly for the first time about whether he believed miranda rights were given too soon to the suspect dzhokhar tsarnaev. can you comment on the suspect being mirandized and whether that was appropriate? >> well, i mean, the decision to mirandize is one that the magistrate made and totally consistent with the laws that we have. we have a two-day period, we were able to question him under the public safety exception. so i think everyone was done appropriately and we got good leads. >> and law enforcement sources we've spoken with are backing that up saying they were a
and that quest for new information seems to have stalled since suspect dzhokhar tsarnaev was read his miranda rights leading some to criticize that move. now the administration is responding to that criticism and pamela is live with that story. i know you're standing at the prison hospital where dzhokhar is being held. what is the administration saying at this hour? >> well, poppy, my colleague brianna keilar spoke to attorney general eric holder last night at the white house...
122
122
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 122
favorite 0
quote 0
holding up miranda warningings, the administration has done something i am relieved b. they seem to recognize you have to question these people . if they are willing to forgo. confessions. they can question him forever. two weeks and only thing that happens, they can't use that material in a criminal trial. they have plenty of other thing to convict him with. they can use for all intelligence. >> there are two ways to that result. convict him without his statement and since he made a confession that is admissible. he made it easier for you. >> you were quoting charles craught -- krauthammer. they want us dead and we have to realize a lot of people wantulse dead. >> it is a shame we need things to remind us of that. that has been true for 35 years. >> and you never let go of your resolve. mayor an honor. >> and another femo who warned about this. commander lipo, the r remember the uss cole predating 9/11. that was the terrorist real salvo to 9/11. he's next, after this. [ male announcer] surprise -- you're having triplets. [ babies crying ] surprise -- your house was bui
holding up miranda warningings, the administration has done something i am relieved b. they seem to recognize you have to question these people . if they are willing to forgo. confessions. they can question him forever. two weeks and only thing that happens, they can't use that material in a criminal trial. they have plenty of other thing to convict him with. they can use for all intelligence. >> there are two ways to that result. convict him without his statement and since he made a...
373
373
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
KNTV
tv
eye 373
favorite 0
quote 0
people thought he should have been not given a miranda warning. it turned out he was questioned for a time and then given his miranda warning and the police said he kept talking. they used it as a textbook example. this will remain a controversial decision. it is the stated policy of the obama administration to take anyone like this who creates a crime in the united states and treat them in the regular civilian justice system. they will take him away. when the appropriate time comes, begin to question him. >> pete, i got an e-mail using a term of art in law enforcement. somebody said, remember, this is a federal show. >> meaning the fbi is in charge. we have already heard some members of the senate say this person should be declared an enemy combatant, not given miranda warning and should be subject to a military-style interrogation. the obama administration will never go for that. they believe suspects who commit crimes here should be treated in the criminal justice system. that's what they will intend to do. >> michael leiter who was, among othe
people thought he should have been not given a miranda warning. it turned out he was questioned for a time and then given his miranda warning and the police said he kept talking. they used it as a textbook example. this will remain a controversial decision. it is the stated policy of the obama administration to take anyone like this who creates a crime in the united states and treat them in the regular civilian justice system. they will take him away. when the appropriate time comes, begin to...
103
103
Apr 27, 2013
04/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 103
favorite 0
quote 0
what about the miranda warning issue. the judge marched in and f.b.i. claims stopped what had been an investigation without a lawyer. that is when he stopped cooperating. >> they were in the room apparently and after only 18 hours of interrogation. >> paul: miranda warnings relates to what would be admissible in court. there is plenty of evidence already likely to convict this fellow. that is not the point of interrogation. we want intelligence to prevent future attacks. to make sure we can break up any current terror networks. >> they invoked the public safety exception, but the more important point, he should have been treated as a potential enemy combatant. we want to know not only what they were trying to do but who his brother and he was in touch with. how was he radicalized helping them or giving any know how. >> and that combatant designation could be withdrawn later and then sent to civilian court. when we come back, as the roll out continues, is obamacare unraveling? one of the chief arc tektsd seems to think so. he is predicting a train wreck
what about the miranda warning issue. the judge marched in and f.b.i. claims stopped what had been an investigation without a lawyer. that is when he stopped cooperating. >> they were in the room apparently and after only 18 hours of interrogation. >> paul: miranda warnings relates to what would be admissible in court. there is plenty of evidence already likely to convict this fellow. that is not the point of interrogation. we want intelligence to prevent future attacks. to make...
159
159
Apr 20, 2013
04/13
by
CNNW
tv
eye 159
favorite 0
quote 0
there is no need for miranda warning in this case. >> if they were to read the miranda rights and say you have the right to remain silent, right to attorney, let's say he gets a public defender or another attorney volunteers to help him, you're a graduate of harvard law school. you know the first thing any lawyer will say to his or her client shut up. don't say anything else. >> we'll see. this is going to unfold slowly now. it's important for people to remember the big statement last night was commitment by the administration they'll go through normal criminal justice process. we have criminal statutes. >> instead of declaring him enemy combatant. >> i personally think it's absurd to be honest. he's here. he is u.s. citizenship and all of the evidence is necessary and it's an important statement especially after what the city went through to say, yep, now you're just a normal criminal and we're going to put you through the process. this national security exception i agree with tom, we do not know a lot of facts about the motivation and whether they had more plans for people. a lot of
there is no need for miranda warning in this case. >> if they were to read the miranda rights and say you have the right to remain silent, right to attorney, let's say he gets a public defender or another attorney volunteers to help him, you're a graduate of harvard law school. you know the first thing any lawyer will say to his or her client shut up. don't say anything else. >> we'll see. this is going to unfold slowly now. it's important for people to remember the big statement...
114
114
Oct 2, 2013
10/13
by
WTTG
tv
eye 114
favorite 0
quote 0
[laughter] >> miranda kerr is in paris for paris fashion week. she just got dropped off at the wrong venue. >> miranda, wrong show? > she is running in her knee high boots. oh, my god, where is the venue. >> she runs like a muppet apparently. >> kate upton is a model coming out of the gym. someone decided to do an extreme close-up of her face and she has blemishes. >> why doesn't she put makeup on or something.
[laughter] >> miranda kerr is in paris for paris fashion week. she just got dropped off at the wrong venue. >> miranda, wrong show? > she is running in her knee high boots. oh, my god, where is the venue. >> she runs like a muppet apparently. >> kate upton is a model coming out of the gym. someone decided to do an extreme close-up of her face and she has blemishes. >> why doesn't she put makeup on or something.
83
83
Apr 21, 2013
04/13
by
KNTV
tv
eye 83
favorite 0
quote 0
the aclu released a statement saying that denying miranda rights is un-american. but there is an exception to the miranda rule if there's a continued threat to public safety. the question everyone wants an answer to now lies with 19-year-old dzhokhar tsarnaev, a naturalized u.s. citizen who's recovering in the hospital. namely, what was behind the attack at the boston marathon. terrorism expert neil smeltser at uc berkeley says the first questions investigators will likely ask tsarnaev will have to do with the motive. >> first psychological is is this some kind of a wayward nut like columbine or some of the school shooters apparently have been? what are the linkages? where's this guy -- who's this guy been linked up to? >> reporter: investigators will also want to know if the 19-year-old suspect planted any other explosives anywhere or if others were involved in the plot. the director of the american civil liberties union reacted to the administration's decision not to immediately mirandize tsarnaev by saying, "every criminal defendant is entitled to be read miran
the aclu released a statement saying that denying miranda rights is un-american. but there is an exception to the miranda rule if there's a continued threat to public safety. the question everyone wants an answer to now lies with 19-year-old dzhokhar tsarnaev, a naturalized u.s. citizen who's recovering in the hospital. namely, what was behind the attack at the boston marathon. terrorism expert neil smeltser at uc berkeley says the first questions investigators will likely ask tsarnaev will...
849
849
Apr 26, 2013
04/13
by
COM
tv
eye 849
favorite 0
quote 0
why did we read him his miranda rights? if anything we should have read him his samantha rights. you give him three cosmos, and, girlfriend, he starts to dish. now, now he knows he has the right to remain silent, and things were going so well. right, "fox & friends"? >> turns out the bombing suspect in boston was singing like a canary until the judge showed up. and read him his rights. >> so before he was read his rights, he apparently was singing like a canary. >> turns out the boston bombing suspect was singing like a canary until the judge showed up. >> turns out the boston bombing suspect was singing like a canary until the judge showed up. >> they were talking to him and he was singing like a canary. >> stephen: yeah, he was singing like a canary. swinging like a pig. dropping a dime like a dirty root rat. a steel, everything was jake we were about to send him to the big house, the slaerm, its gray bar hotel. it was all-- it was all eggs and coves until the chief got hirchgy and gave us a double-cross, the runaround, the high hoot. that's what's eating me, see? i should fix
why did we read him his miranda rights? if anything we should have read him his samantha rights. you give him three cosmos, and, girlfriend, he starts to dish. now, now he knows he has the right to remain silent, and things were going so well. right, "fox & friends"? >> turns out the bombing suspect in boston was singing like a canary until the judge showed up. and read him his rights. >> so before he was read his rights, he apparently was singing like a canary....
137
137
Apr 26, 2013
04/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 137
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> the other thing, the miranda rights, you have your miranda rights whether they are read to you or not. >> that's the thing. that's what i was talking about. the romance of reading the right. it is absurd. we have rights and we don't read them. to me miranda is the equivalent of civil rights. it is like reminding black people they don't have to sit at the back of the bus every time they get on the bus. >> i am so glad you both say that. if i could mention that -- >> that was a great analogy. >> yes, it was very good. >> i was actually looking at it from the complete flip side of you, tom. my view is, and this is to me i don't understand, but conservatives now seem to be arguing the government gives us these rights and can withhold them. it is an old position for conservatives to take. my point is, you have this right and the government may not infringe upon whether they tell you or not. unless a confession is voluntary it can't be used against you in a court of law. it doesn't mean no one in authority can never ask you a question. and to tom's point, if it happens to be true that w
. >> the other thing, the miranda rights, you have your miranda rights whether they are read to you or not. >> that's the thing. that's what i was talking about. the romance of reading the right. it is absurd. we have rights and we don't read them. to me miranda is the equivalent of civil rights. it is like reminding black people they don't have to sit at the back of the bus every time they get on the bus. >> i am so glad you both say that. if i could mention that -- >>...